The Judge
There is a woman, who was in a class of mine for two weeks. She also stayed in Clare College with me, her name isn’t important, because I always just think of her as the judge. The second day of class, I had noticed that the class registrar said, “judge” before her name so after that I decided to talk to her about her profession.
The judge is an old woman, I would say mid to late sixties. She cannot walk well, and does not use a cane, she must have been too proud to do so because she really could have used one. She knew a lot about all sorts of things, and one could tell that in her day she was a good looking woman, a power woman. She went to UC Berkley and then to University of San Francisco’s Law School. She told me that she went to Law School at a time where there were few women in the business, and she had received a lot of lip for it. I told her it was good that women in her generation helped pave the way for women in my generation, and it’s true. She was a lawyer during the times of Harvey Milk in San Francisco, and knew the mayor before he was shot. This woman has seen a lot, and there she was sitting in class a couple rows in front of me.
She has a husband, and her husband was with her but not in my classes. I saw them at breakfast, if there were other people at the table then they chatted. If they were alone, they didn’t say a word to each other. They usually left the table at different times, without even a word of dismissal, no “see you later honey” or anything like that. They always sat together during the mundane plenary lecture. Her husband was a finance guy in San Francisco. In their day, they really were a power couple, at least in terms of career choices.
The judge liked me; I always called her “the honorable” just because I thought it was fun. Since I had met her, I was always trying to find an opportunity to ask her about being a judge, since I am thinking about going to Law School I thought she could shed some interesting light. One day, my opportunity came.
She was a general common pleas judge, I believe. She told me that she never was bribed and that for the most part California wasn’t an area where those things happened. “That happens in the south” or “Chicago” and places like that she said. Her favorite kind of cases were corporate fraud, because there was a smart thief and it would be a puzzle to try and figure out what he or she had been doing to steal the millions.
Upon being asked some of the difficulties of being a judge she told me this story:
“When I was first starting out, I was in Small Claims Court. It’s for smaller incidents, and there aren’t any lawyers. I had this trial with an older middle-aged woman and a “kid.” When I say kid I mean someone 18 or 19. The woman was one of those bossy types, she was ordering people around my courtroom before the case and already she had started to rub me the wrong way. She was bringing the kid to court saying that he had backed into her at an intersection. Right away, I thought this case was ridiculous. How often is it that someone backs into you while driving on the road? She gets up there, and says, ‘I’m a very careful driver’ and I told her that we don’t take that into consideration and all I need to know is what happened. ‘The light turned yellow, and I stopped of course, but he backed right into me.’ Again I was thinking this is a ridiculous case… So I tell the kid to tell me what happened, and he gets up there and says ‘I did back into her, my car shifted out of gear.’ I was surprised and I asked,
‘Why are you contesting it then?’ and he told me it was because the woman was charging him for damage that he could not have possibly of done. Well, I hadn’t been taking notes on damages because I had written that case off without hearing the story. After that I always took careful notes on both sides, on everything. As a judge you never know where the story is going to go and you have to put aside your own personal judgments when you are working.”
I smiled at the judge, and told her that it was a very interesting story. I really enjoyed it. After that I didn’t really see her too much, and now she is back in California, doing what retired judges do. I will most likely never see her again. Nonetheless, her story will probably last with me forever. All this because I read the class roster and saw “judge” in front of her name.

